India’s stiff 50% tariff is a US sanction in disguise
Washington has taken its brinksmanship against New Delhi to a dangerous level. oil-buys”>Doubling an already-high tariff of 25% is bad enough. What makes it worse for Prime Minister Narendra Modi is the language. President Donald Trump has decided to call India’s additional punishment for importing Russian oil a “secondary” tariff, a made-up term that has a close cousin in the world of sanctions.
Secondary sanctions impose a cost on third parties for allegedly enabling bad behaviour by someone else. If a US bank, port, ship, or company is prohibited from engaging in a transaction involving the Russian financial system, then a secondary sanction can make it potentially illegal for non-Americans, too.
New Delhi should be wary. The goal of the punitive tax is to get Russian President Vladimir Putin to end the Ukraine War. If that objective is not realized, there’s no guarantee of what the White House might do next to the world’s biggest buyer of seaborne Russian crude.
Also Read: Mint Quick Edit: Can US tariffs survive legal scrutiny?
A sanction masquerading as tariff is just Trump being innovative. A more conventional tool is the Specially Designated Nationals list, maintained by the Office of Foreign Assets Control in the US Treasury.
State-owned Indian refiners are already pulling back from the Russian trade. If they start showing up on the SDN list, it would become difficult for others to do business with them. No amount of nationalistic bluster can mitigate the seriousness of that threat.
To lose access to the US currency or the Western-controlled banking system would be a far bigger setback than a 50% tariff. Even large Indian tycoons will not want to needle Trump. Russian crude has been the biggest source of oil for Mukesh Ambani’s refinery this year. His rival billionaire Gautam Adani doesn’t have any exposure to oil, but he has some legal trouble with the US government. He also has a vast port network.
What’s the way out then? In an interview with Reuters, Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, who’s also been handed penal tariffs of 50%, floated a trial balloon: a joint response by Brics. Modi, who spoke on the phone with Lula for nearly an hour Thursday, is expected to head to China this month—for the first time in seven years.
Also Read: Rethink policy: Let’s take Trump’s tariff tirade as an opportunity for tax reforms
Marshalling a unified front to challenge Trump’s overreach might make sense for Brazil, but ratcheting up the confrontation with Washington should hold no appeal for India.
Brazil’s biggest export market is China, with whom it has a $49 billion trade surplus. India, on the other hand, sells just about $32 billion annually to Brazil, Russia and China — combined. The US buys nearly three times as much from it, in addition to providing tens of thousands of work visas each year to Indian techies.
Washington also controls the student-visa pipeline for (among others) children of local politicians, bureaucrats, tycoons and bankers. If India wants to go on a collision course with Trump, the elite would balk.
The Modi government must switch its focus. What started off as a US-China trade and technology war has turned into a much bigger play for absolute American dominance. There is no point now in negotiating a discount on the 25% reciprocal tariff. Let that be handled as part of a broader trade deal. Getting the secondary tax cancelled in Trump’s three-week grace period has to be the more immediate goal.
Also Read: The Mexico loophole: How exporters could dodge Trump’s tariffs
Even if India succeeds in that limited objective, the ruling BJP’s political opponents may not let the government run a victory lap. “India, please understand: The reason PM Modi cannot stand up to President Trump despite his repeated threats is the ongoing US investigation into Adani,” Rahul Gandhi, leader of the opposition in parliament, wrote in a post on X. This was in the context of Adani’s legal entanglement in the US over an alleged bribery scheme involving a solar-energy contract. The Adani Group has refuted the allegations as baseless and said it’s fully compliant with all laws.
The secondary tariff is just Trump-speak for a display of America’s power over non-Americans.
Reliance’s oil-refining business is trying to diversify away from Russia.
There is no other option. Trade disputes can still be taken to the World Trade Organization, but in the realm of sanctions, might is the only rule—and the dollar the only currency. Leaders like Lula and Modi can protest the former, but no savvy businessman in their countries can do without the latter. ©Bloomberg
The author is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist
Post Comment