Rahul Gandhi moves away from allies, family in balancing act on Israel | Political Pulse News
Senior Congress leader Rahul Gandhi’s support for strong ties with Israel due to “strategic interests”, while condemning both the October 7, 2023, attacks by Hamas on civilians in Israel, and Israel’s war on Gaza since, is a moderation from the party’s stand and has drawn condemnation from its allies.
While both Sonia Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra have used the word “genocide” while describing Israel’s actions in Gaza, Gandhi’s remarks – during an interaction at University of Chicago this week – are, in fact, closer to the position maintained by the Indian government led by Narendra Modi, which has sought to balance ties between Israel and the Arab world.
In a sharp reaction on Saturday, former Kerala chief minister Pinarayi Vijayan, whose party CPI(M) is a close ally of the Congress at the Centre, said Gandhi’s remarks “expose the Congress party’s glaring hypocrisy on Palestine”. “His pro-imperialist position undermines the legacy of Nehru, whose foreign policy stood firmly against imperialism and in solidarity with the Palestinian struggle,” Vijayan posted on X.
Another ally, the CPI(ML) Liberation, called for an end to India’s relationship with Israel. Describing it as a “genocidal regime”, CPI (ML) Liberation general secretary Dipankar Bhattacharya said there could be no strategic relationship with a State that continued to perpetrate genocide against “children, women and common people despite global condemnation”.
Gandhi’s call for strong ties with Israel is also striking because the Modi government has been criticised for its perceived closeness to Israel PM Benjamin Netanyahu, whose hawkish policy has driven the war on Gaza. Modi visited Israel just days before the US and Israel launched their attacks on Iran on February 28 this year.
Gandhi shared his remarks on Israel, during a conversation with Professor Robert Pape at the University of Chicago, on X. The Congress leader said: “India’s foreign policy must be guided by what is good for India… I support a strong relationship with Israel. We have strategic interests, including buying the best weapons for our armed forces.”
At the same time, this “cannot mean silence on Gaza”, Gandhi said. “I condemn the October 7th attacks and the killing of innocent people. I also condemn what Israel has done in Gaza. One wrong cannot justify another… We are a nation of 1.5 billion people. No country – Israel, USA, Russia or China – should hold us back from playing our rightful role on the global stage. India must stand for what it believes in.”
Gandhi’s sister and senior Congress leader Vadra has been among the most critical voices in the party when it comes to Israel. On August 12, 2025, she accused the Israeli government of committing “genocide” and said it is “shameful” that the Indian government is standing “silent” on this. She has also worn Palestine tote bags as a symbol of her support.
In June, in an op-ed in The Indian Express, Sonia Gandhi wrote: “The calculus of national interest demands that we respond to the global public opinion against the Israeli regime’s genocidal actions in Gaza and its brutal displacement and dispossession of lakhs of Palestinian families in the occupied West Bank. The Modi government’s continued silence simply cannot be explained rationally or morally.”
In a response to Vadra’s remarks, Israeli Ambassador to India Reuven Azar had said: “What is shameful is your deceit. Israel killed 25,000 Hamas terrorists. The terrible cost in human lives derives from Hamas’s heinous tactics of hiding behind civilians, their shooting of people trying to evacuate or receive assistance and their rocket fire… Israel facilitated 2 million tonnes of food into Gaza while Hamas tries to sequester them, thereby creating hunger. Gaza population has grown 450 per cent in the last 50 years, no genocide there. Don’t buy Hamas numbers.”
The Congress itself has treaded more carefully, with its historic support for Palestine requiring a modulation after the October 7, 2023, attacks by Hamas. The Congress initially refrained from naming Hamas and using the word “terror” to describe the attacks. But party leaders like Shashi Tharoor questioned this, seeking at a meeting of the Congress Working Committee (CWC) on October 9, 2023, that a resolution be passed condemning the attacks, naming the outfit and using the word terror.
While the CWC ignored the suggestion, soon afterwards, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge condemned “the brutal attacks by Hamas on the people of Israel”, adding that “the indiscriminate actions by Israel’s military forces in civilian areas, that includes a siege of the Gaza Strip and bombings in it” were also “unacceptable”.
Later, the Congress joined Left parties in slamming the Modi government after India abstained from voting at the UN General Assembly on a resolution drafted by Arab states calling for an immediate truce between Israel and Hamas and demanding aid access to the Gaza Strip.
In his post Saturday criticising Rahul Gandhi, Vijayan said: “At a time when Gaza is witnessing one of the most devastating genocides of our time, with thousands of innocent children among its victims, he openly advocates stronger ties with Israel and arms purchases from a state responsible for their slaughter. His attempt to strike a diplomatic balancing act in the face of this catastrophe is indefensible… There can be no balancing act when humanity is on trial.”
In a Facebook post, sharing a report on Gandhi’s comments, CPI (ML) Liberation leader Bhattacharya said: “Just as there could be no strategic relationship with Nazi Germany or the apartheid state of South Africa, there can be no normalising, condoning or downplaying of the genocide in Gaza or the cruel colonial occupation of Palestine by Israel.”
He added: “India’s existing strategic relationship with Israel, the growing Adani-led corporate trade including arms supply, and sinister use of Israel’s surveillance technology and security model has already done enough damage to India’s international image, foreign policy credibility and above all the health of our own internal democracy and governance. We must end it sooner rather than later and must not rationalise it in the name of India’s defence or ‘national security’ needs.”